IND vs ENG: 'Far too defensive' - Former India cricketer urges captain Shubman Gill to be more aggressive
Former India cricketer Sanjay Manjrekar has weighed in on Shubman Gill's captaincy in the wake of India's five-wicket defeat to England in the first Test at Headingley. While acknowledging Gill's composure and talent as a batter, Manjrekar cautioned the young skipper against being too defensive in his approach, especially when conditions are in India's favour.
Go Beyond The Boundary with our YouTube channel. SUBSCRIBE NOW!
Speaking on Star Sports' Game Plan, Manjrekar said Gill is “sorted” as a batter at No. 4 and will only improve with experience. “I just hope he can carry on after getting to a 108 or 120 because now he knows what could happen if he gets out. So that is something he will start doing,” he said.
However, it was Gill's field placements and leadership that drew greater scrutiny. “Overcast conditions, I know the ball wasn't doing too much, but they pre-empted the English approach and had a far too defensive field,” Manjrekar noted. “I hate to bring Virat Kohli as a comparison because it's unfair on the young man, but you can just imagine Virat Kohli in that situation.”
“Whether they would have got wickets or not, Kohli would have shown the opposition that he's trying to get them out. Gill is not that kind of personality, nor that kind of captain. But maybe don't go so defensive pre-empting things,” he added.
Manjrekar also praised Rishabh Pant's hunger and resilience, saying he is likely to carry his twin tons into the second Test. At the same time, he warned KL Rahul to maintain consistency. “KL Rahul cannot be a one-hundred wonder or a one-Test-match performer. Indian cricket needs him badly,” he said.
The second Test begins Wednesday at Edgbaston, with India trailing 0-1 in the five-match series.
Game On Season 1 continues with Mirabai Chanu’s inspiring story. Watch Episode 2 here.
Speaking on Star Sports' Game Plan, Manjrekar said Gill is “sorted” as a batter at No. 4 and will only improve with experience. “I just hope he can carry on after getting to a 108 or 120 because now he knows what could happen if he gets out. So that is something he will start doing,” he said.
However, it was Gill's field placements and leadership that drew greater scrutiny. “Overcast conditions, I know the ball wasn't doing too much, but they pre-empted the English approach and had a far too defensive field,” Manjrekar noted. “I hate to bring Virat Kohli as a comparison because it's unfair on the young man, but you can just imagine Virat Kohli in that situation.”
Manjrekar also praised Rishabh Pant's hunger and resilience, saying he is likely to carry his twin tons into the second Test. At the same time, he warned KL Rahul to maintain consistency. “KL Rahul cannot be a one-hundred wonder or a one-Test-match performer. Indian cricket needs him badly,” he said.
The second Test begins Wednesday at Edgbaston, with India trailing 0-1 in the five-match series.
Game On Season 1 continues with Mirabai Chanu’s inspiring story. Watch Episode 2 here.
Top Comment
Thakur
1 day ago
As always we can just ignore what he says… bowling needs to be worked kn batting was super aggressive…Read allPost comment
Popular from Sports
- Chess | 'In North India, we're trained thugs': The harsh truth behind the nation's North-South divide
- IND vs ENG, 2nd Test predicted playing XI: Jasprit Bumrah to be rested? Two spinners to play against England at Edgbaston
- IPL: 'Cameraman manages to find me', Kavya Maran addresses why she's become queen of internet memes
- Miyaan Magic! Mohammed Siraj joins Virat Kohli with off-field venture - complete details
- “Their body language suggest something…”: Taylor Swift and Travis Kelce's subtle body language during NYC dinner hints at their true connection
end of article
Featured in sports
- IND vs ENG: Gill gives major update on Bumrah - 'We'll take the call ...'
- IND vs ENG, 2nd Test: Stokes calls Pant ‘very dangerous’, says England ready to reset
- IND vs ENG Test: It was incredible...' - Harry Brook on skipping IPL
- IND vs ENG: Arshdeep Singh hits back at troll, screenshot goes viral
- 'It felt bad to be out of Olympics, I was crying': Manika Batra opens up on heartbreaks, personal goals, and more
- To play Jasprit Bumrah or not? Ravi Shastri offers his suggestion
International Sports
- “F*ck ‘em all, That’s my QB”: Maxx Crosby defends Geno Smith after viral backlash
- David Bakhtiari’s wedding remark reignites buzz around Aaron Rodgers’ private marriage
- Sources: T.J. Watt trade buzz grows as Steelers star skips minicamp over contract
- “You can’t be Tom Brady”: Ex-Patriots star says QBs need to stop chasing the impossible
- “Not super hopeful”: Analyst slams Steelers’ offense, questions Aaron Rodgers’ ability to deliver
Trending Stories
- JAC Class 11 results 2025 declared at jacresults.com with 98.7% pass rate
- ITR filing FY 2024-25: Why filing Income Tax Return is important even if you have no tax to pay - explained
- Karnataka 2nd PUC Exam 3 Result 2025 Live Update: Only 22% students pass, result link active at karresults.nic.in
- Indian Railways launches new ‘super app’ RailOne: Book IRCTC train tickets, track PNR, food, rail enquiry in one place - what it means for passengers
- IBPS PO 2025: Registration starts for 5208 posts at ibps.in, check direct link to apply here
- Karnataka 2nd PUC exam 3 result 2025 likely to be declared today: Check when and where to access score cards at karresults.nic.in
- “Their body language suggest something…”: Taylor Swift and Travis Kelce's subtle body language during NYC dinner hints at their true connection
Photostories
- 5 everyday habits that are weakening your bones
- From beetroot juice to lemon water: Top Harvard doctor ranks 9 best and worst drinks for liver health
- US-based doctor shares 5-minute daily habits that could improve heart health and save millions of lives
- Morning bloating and gas? 7 daily habits that leave you bloated and uncomfortable by sunrise
- Kajol, Alia Bhatt, Anushka Sharma: Bollywood divas who turned killers in movies
- Mexico’s Island of Dolls: What's the truth behind the decaying dolls that hang from trees
- Countries from PM Modi’s 5-nation tour worth adding to your travel bucket list
- Fresh romances and unseen chemistry: Bollywood’s new on-screen couples of 2025
- Ananya Panday to Janhvi Kapoor: Rekha-inspired Anarkali suits donned by Bollywood actresses
- 5 paintings that are described by people as gory, disturbing, and triggering
Top Trends
Up Next