There is little that is ever easy about free agency, and the offseason has been a particularly turbulent one in the case of Max Kepler. The outfielder went to winter seeking to find his value again after a difficult season in a new place. In its place, a 80-game suspension by the Major League Baseball has made his career path and his defense more complicated. Kepler was only 33 years old, and the market was already becoming cautious due to cost teams and limited long-term commitments.
Front offices have to consider now missed time, limitations on eligibility and uncertainty on his role. What appeared to be a small comeback chance, has evolved into a waiting game that can probably continue throughout the season.
Why MLB’s 80-game suspension has made Max Kepler’s free agency uncertain
Kepler was suspended by the league Joint Drug Prevention and Treatment Program on account of admitting to a positive test of Epitrenbolone, a prohibited performance-enhancing drug under the league. ESPN reporter Alden Gonza ran a story claiming that MLB and Kepler had reached a settlement that would allow the suspension to be fulfilled despite him not being in an active roster at the time of the season opener. That is to avoid the delaying of the suspension merely because he has not signed.
This is, however, limited in a major way. However, Kepler will not even qualify in 2026 despite having served the suspension. That is a condition that weighs heavily on teams that have playoff ambitions. The clubs that make plans outside of the normal season might be reluctant to give a club and salary to a player who will not play at any time in October no matter how he performs in the second half of the year.
The fact that Kepler was already in an awkward situation in front of being suspended is due to the fact that he already spent a season with the Philadelphia Phillies. Though he still cleared 18 home runs, his performance saw a decline, and he ended up with a 90 wRC + and a slash line of.216/.300/.391. He also lamented that he was protected against left handed pitching and he thought he would have an everyday role once he left Minnesota Twins after the 2024 campaign.
There is not much room to make mistakes in the bigger market. Top outfielders such as Kyle Tucker and Cody Bellinger top the list though teams that might need less expensive depth may be interested in players with cleaner rooms.
Harrison Bader, Miguel Andujar, Austin Hays or Mike Tauchman are just some of the options that do not have complications of suspension. To Kepler, it is a matter of time and time will tell. A robust bounce back would revitalize the interest but until then, his free agency is characterized by uncertainty and timing.