Browns GM faces fallout from $230M blunder following Amari Cooper trade, as per NFL Insider

As the NFL season heats up, teams on the brink are making tough choices to shake up their rosters. The Cleveland Browns, once hopeful, are now facing a daunting reality after securing Deshaun Watson with a fully guaranteed $230 million contract. With Watson sidelined due to an Achilles injury, the team’s struggles have been magnified, leading to their first major move: trading Amari Cooper to the Buffalo Bills. This trade could be just the beginning of a much-needed overhaul for a franchise desperately seeking to reclaim its competitive edge.


Also Read: Former NFL star questions Panthers HC Dave Canales' competency ahead of firing threats aimed at David Tepper

Impact of Watson's injury and Cooper's Trade on Cleveland's Future

As the NFL season unfolds, struggling teams are faced with tough decisions to clear the way for new talent. The Cleveland Browns find themselves in this predicament, grappling with escalating challenges after giving Deshaun Watson a fully guaranteed $230 million contract. With Watson sidelined for the season due to an Achilles injury, the Browns are compelled to make significant roster adjustments, beginning with Amari Cooper’s trade to the Buffalo Bills.

This trade clearly signals that the Browns are “open for business,” as highlighted by analyst Albert Breer on The Rich Eisen Show. With a dismal 1-6 record following a loss to the Washington Commanders, playoff aspirations have all but vanished. In return for Cooper, the Browns received just a third-round pick in 2025 and a seventh-round pick in 2026—far from a satisfactory haul.

For Cooper, however, this trade could be a silver lining, as it presents him with an “increased role” and more opportunities with the Bills. As the Browns navigate the fallout from Watson’s hefty contract, their upcoming moves will undoubtedly shape the franchise's future in the league.

Did Deshaun Watson mess up the Cleveland Browns?

We'll delve into the salary cap implications shortly, but first, let's take a closer look at Deshaun Watson's performance. Over the past three seasons, he hasn’t played more than seven games in a single year. His recent matchup against the Bengals marked just his 19th appearance in three years—a clear red flag for what many consider a dismal investment.

To make matters worse, Watson is set to earn a staggering base salary of $45 million this year. If the Browns were to release him prematurely, they would face a hefty dead cap hit of $200.7 million. If they choose to part ways next year, the financial burden doesn’t ease much, with a cap hit of $172.7 million looming. Currently, it seems like the Browns have no viable exit strategy.

According to a copy of Watson’s contract obtained by ESPN, the Browns have up to $13.9 million of Watson’s 2024 salary insured and up to $44.2 million of his 2025 salary insured.” Meanwhile, as Breer noted, the Browns might soon receive inquiries about key players like Myles Garrett and Z'Darius Smith. If the situation worsens, Cleveland could be forced to part ways with their franchise-caliber talent.

Also Read: Tom Brady’s best friends reveal struggles with Patrick Mahomes after Rob Gronkowski chooses Chiefs benefit over loyalty