Motion for Speaker's removal defeated after fiery debate in Parliament
NEW DELHI: Opposition's resolution for the removal of Speaker Om Birla was defeated in Lok Sabha with a voice vote on Wednesday following a two-day discussion that concluded with home minister Amit Shah's fiery counterattack, which especially targeted Rahul Gandhi. Shah slammed the bid to put the chair's "dignity" in the dock and asked opposition parties not to treat the House like a "mela" where anything goes, reports Kumar Rakesh.
Birla is set to return to his seat on Thursday - he had decided not to chair its proceedings from Feb 10 when 120 opposition MPs submitted their notice for his removal for allegedly partisan conduct. The discussion was marked by a robust debate as both sides tried to push their narratives, with opposition members attacking the govt for allegedly undermining institutions and muzzling their voice, and the ruling alliance attributing the rare motion against the Speaker to the frustration of its opponents over their electoral losses and the sense of privilege harboured by Congress's Gandhi family.
The division of votes on the motion could not take place as opposition MPs were in the well demanding Shah’s apology over his use of an “unparliamentary” word. He urged the chair to expunge it if it was unparliamentary, but protests continued, forcing BJP MP Jagdambika Pal, who was in the chair, to go for a voice vote. Shah said that the Speaker, as the custodian of the House, has the right to discipline unruly members. “Mic for those who do not follow rules should be cut off,” he said, asserting that the chair is entitled to delete unparliamentary words used by members and even remove MPs if they persist with conduct that is out of line with norms in place for decades.
Select The Times of India as your preferred source on Google Search
Israel Iran War
- US-Israel-Iran War News Live Updates: Saudi intercepts drone headed to Shaybah oil field; Israeli strikes 10 Hezbollah targets in Beirut
- Middle Easat crisis: MEA condemns attack on India-bound Thai ship; remarks innocent lives lost in conflict 'unacceptable'
- 'Legitimate targets': Iran issues warning to US tech firms including Google, Amazon, Microsoft, Nvidia
The division of votes on the motion could not take place as opposition MPs were in the well demanding Shah’s apology over his use of an “unparliamentary” word. He urged the chair to expunge it if it was unparliamentary, but protests continued, forcing BJP MP Jagdambika Pal, who was in the chair, to go for a voice vote. Shah said that the Speaker, as the custodian of the House, has the right to discipline unruly members. “Mic for those who do not follow rules should be cut off,” he said, asserting that the chair is entitled to delete unparliamentary words used by members and even remove MPs if they persist with conduct that is out of line with norms in place for decades.
Select The Times of India as your preferred source on Google Search
Top Comment
C
Cool Analyst
4 hours ago
While many MPs in opposition find that LOP is just wasting LS time & not giving any opportunity for healthy debates that are leading for betterment of country. These LS members go to LS.. sit & eat canteen food then comeback to home.LOP is not able to find real failures of BJP. So it just creates useless drama forever.. but indirectly helping BJPRead allPost comment
Popular from India
- Close shave for Farooq Abdullah: Man aims gun at ex-J&K CM, pinned down in time - CCTV footage
- SC imposes life ban on three academics for 'corruption' chapter, seeks action on posts
- INDIA bloc MPs back TMC's motion to remove CEC Gyanesh Kumar; notice likely in Parliament soon
- No-confidence motion against Lok Sabha Speaker Om Birla defeated by voice vote amid opposition protest
- MEA condemns attack on India-bound Thai ship, says innocent lives lost in conflict 'unacceptable'
end of article
Trending Stories
- IPL 2026 team-wise full schedule: Complete list of matches, dates, time and venues
- US-Israel-Iran War News Live Updates: Saudi intercepts drone headed to Shaybah oil field; Israeli strikes 10 Hezbollah targets in Beirut
- World Cup snub and father's death: RCB star reveals painful journey
- Pakistan cricketer Mohammad Rizwan's 'I don't watch India's matches' remark resurfaces after Bangladesh humiliation
- 'India bigger than Pakistan': Imad Wasim slams critics downplaying T20 World Cup triumph
- Who is Celestium? Twitch bans pink haired VTuber streamer for hateful conduct as she claims mass reports and fights suspension
- Frank Leboeuf slams Ronald Araujo for embarrassing Champions League moment as Barcelona survive tense Newcastle draw
Featured in India
- Farooq survives assassination bid at wedding, gunman held
08:26 Motion to remove Speaker brought to satisfy Rahul's ego: BJP- Rahul Gandhi targets PM Modi, says it's the 1st time opposition leader was gagged
- West Asia tension: India reviews situation with Russia, EU
06:21 EAM Jaishankar, Iran minister touch base for 3rd time since war, discuss Strait of Hormuz- You turned us into terrorists, says TMC MP as opposition slams Birla
Photostories
- 7 poor habits that drain your brain and hurt productivity - And how to fix them, explains CMC Vellore doctor
- Protein powders and high-protein diets: Kidney experts explain the hidden risks and the balanced way to build muscle without straining your kidneys
- Devoleena Bhattacharjee gets emotional recalling caring for her mother during schizophrenia attacks from the age of 11; says brother’s death led to a phase of depression
- A red Chanderi saree, royal bandhgala and Mumbai sunset: Pictures from Kritika Kamra-Gaurav Kapur's intimate Bandra home wedding
- Mahesh Babu-Namrata Shirodkar: Love story born on 'Vamsi' sets, sealed in private vows
- Hardik Pandya to Abhishek Sharma: Indian players flash diamond studs and chains during T20 World Cup 2026 triumph
- 5 key features that make cruiser bikes comfortable for highway riding
- How to make South Indian Curd Rice for dinner to keep the stomach cool
- The ‘3-hour dinner rule’: Doctors say this simple change could improve heart health and longevity
- Is collecting airline miles still worth it? 5 things travellers should know
Videos
05:24 No LPG Shortage: Govt Unveils Plan To Prioritise Homes, Hospitals, Schools05:52 Preparing Against Joint China & Pakistan Threat, India Buys More Weapons Than Any Nation : Report14:48 ‘Parliament Is Not A Party Office’: TMC’s Sayani Ghosh Targets Modi Govt During Speaker Trust Motion06:56 Lok Sabha Drama Ends With Voice Vote Defeating Opposition Move Against Speaker Om Birla08:05 First Group Of Indian Students In Iran To Head Towards Armenia Border Amid Security Concerns08:26 ‘FOMO Gandhi’: BJP MP Anurag Thakur's Viral Dig At Rahul Gandhi, Calls Him 'Leader Of Propaganda'07:12 'Speaker Above Party Lines': Amit Shah Attacks Congress Over Rare Lok Sabha No Confidence Motion03:07 Learning from Iran, Indian Army Conducts Live Firing Drill Against Drone Swarms At Pokhran07:37 PM Modi Assures Safety Of Indians Amid West Asia War, Slams Cong-Left For ‘Creating Panic’
Up Next