MLB trade rumors: Toronto Blue Jays expected to chase former $140 million Chicago Cubs All-Star in free agency to bolster rotation

The Toronto Blue Jays are preparing for a major change. There are a lot of ongoing doubts around Bo Bichette and his long-term place on the roster. As a result, the club is considering free-agent outfielder Kyle Tucker as a serious replacement. What once looked like speculation has turned into a real plan that could help improve the team’s core.Toronto’s front office appears ready to move forward without waiting on Bichette talks. The priority of the team is to add a top-level bat and lock it in for years. Kyle Tucker fits that goal, and ownership has shown it is willing to spend at a level the franchise has never reached before.The Toronto Blue Jays are expected to push payroll beyond $304 million, a franchise high. Kyle Tucker’s potential deal is projected between $300 million and $418 million over ten years, keeping him under contract through his prime seasons. That would put his annual salary in the $30-40 million range.This approach stands in contrast to shorter offers on the table elsewhere, including a four-year, high-value proposal tied to the New York Mets. Toronto’s pitch is about length and stability, with possible opt-outs built in. Tucker has taken a patient approach to free agency since his time with the Chicago Cubs and Houston Astros, and the Blue Jays are matching that pace.On the field, Tucker gives Toronto what it lacks: a reliable middle-order hitter with power, patience, and strong defense in right field. Placing him alongside Vladimir Guerrero Jr. changes how opposing teams pitch and brings balance to the lineup.Off the field, the move also clears a path forward. Bichette’s trade value would likely rise, giving Toronto options rather than forcing a decision. Tucker gains long-term security and joins a team built to compete, supported by a pitching staff designed to win now.Tucker turns 29 on January 17. A long-term deal would cover ages 29 through 38. He is a four-time All-Star with a World Series title, factors that continue to drive his market value.There are real costs involved in the process of signing Tucker. Luxury tax penalties would be heavy, and Tucker missed time in 2024. Toronto also risks short-term clubhouse tension as Bichette’s situation plays out. Playing in a colder market than New York or Los Angeles is another factor.Also read: MLB trade rumors: Los Angeles Dodgers could bag $240 million Toronto Blue Jays superstar and here's whyEven so, this move would signal a clear direction. Tucker becomes a central piece, Bichette likely moves on, and the Blue Jays position themselves to challenge the top teams in the American League for years to come.