Pay to drive into south Mumbai: BJP leader pushes congestion tax to cut traffic and pollution
MUMBAI: BJP corporator Makarand Narwekar has urged BMC to come out with a policy to implement congestion tax in the central business districts like south Mumbai and use the revenue generated to improve the city's air quality. He wants BMC to tax private vehicles with single occupants entering high-traffic zones.
Last year, MMRDA had discussed a proposal to levy a congestion fee on vehicles that spend 50 minutes or less in Bandra-Kurla Complex to ease traffic congestion in the area. However, the proposal has not moved ahead.
Transport experts believe that congestion pricing is a good idea for Mumbai, if it is implemented in a holistic manner. Amit Bhatt, India managing director of The International Council on Clean Transportation, said globally, cities are trying to manage the number of vehicles on the roads.
Even car-producing countries like China have restricted the number of vehicles registered. One way of managing the number of vehicles on the roads is by restricting the registration of vehicles, and the other way is by imposing congestion tax. Cities like London, New York, and Singapore have congestion tax to manage the number of vehicles on the roads.
"If the number of vehicles increase beyond threshold, the city will be gridlocked. Unlike the West, we have heterogeneous vehicles on the road. The policy should be implemented in a slightly holistic manner and the money generated should be used for sustainable transport," he said.
Endorsing the idea of congestion pricing, A V Shenoy of Mumbai Mobility Forum, said: "About 400-500 vehicles are registered every day and whatever flyovers you build, they will not be able to accommodate these many vehicles. However, what is required is good public transport for those who don't get cars. Congestion pricing and good public transport should go hand in hand."
Narwekar suggested that high-traffic zones could be demarcated using existing CCTV networks and Automatic Number Plate Recognition cameras at entry points.
"BMC should identify traffic-prone spots in the city and deliberate on the idea of congestion tax by charging vehicles for entering high-traffic zones. There should be a facility for automatic deduction via FASTag at checkpoints. This policy can be implemented in congested central business districts like south Mumbai on a pilot basis. This tax will also discourage unnecessary vehicle usage and encourage public transportation," the BP corporator added.
Transport experts believe that congestion pricing is a good idea for Mumbai, if it is implemented in a holistic manner. Amit Bhatt, India managing director of The International Council on Clean Transportation, said globally, cities are trying to manage the number of vehicles on the roads.
Even car-producing countries like China have restricted the number of vehicles registered. One way of managing the number of vehicles on the roads is by restricting the registration of vehicles, and the other way is by imposing congestion tax. Cities like London, New York, and Singapore have congestion tax to manage the number of vehicles on the roads.
"If the number of vehicles increase beyond threshold, the city will be gridlocked. Unlike the West, we have heterogeneous vehicles on the road. The policy should be implemented in a slightly holistic manner and the money generated should be used for sustainable transport," he said.
Endorsing the idea of congestion pricing, A V Shenoy of Mumbai Mobility Forum, said: "About 400-500 vehicles are registered every day and whatever flyovers you build, they will not be able to accommodate these many vehicles. However, what is required is good public transport for those who don't get cars. Congestion pricing and good public transport should go hand in hand."
Narwekar suggested that high-traffic zones could be demarcated using existing CCTV networks and Automatic Number Plate Recognition cameras at entry points.
You Can Also Check: Mumbai AQI
|
Bank Holidays in Mumbai |
Gold Rate Today in Mumbai |
Silver Rate Today in Mumbai
Top Comment
C
Chetan Bordawekar
15 days ago
This is the case that some transport analysts have been trying for a congestion tax for a long time. Now this issue has been raised by the corporator of Colaba, Makarand Narvekar. There are many errors in this. 1. What is the purpose of the road tax or one-time tax or life-time tax that we pay? Is there a need to pay toll again? 2. South Mumbai is no longer a single densely populated area, but large commercial complexes have come up in many places like BKC, Andheri, Lower Parel. So will congestion tax be imposed there too?3. Everyone knows that there are countless streets or roads to come to South Mumbai, where will you collect it from?4. There are also numerous slum complexes in the Colaba Nariman Point area of South Mumbai. Will the cars of the residents there also be taxed? Numerous cars are given by these corporates which are registered in South Mumbai, so will they also have to pay tax? Will congestion tax be exempted for residents or for cars registered in South Mumbai? Who is exempted or only leaders and industrialists are exempted because we have seen that when a leader leaves, 15 to 20 cars follow him. The same thing happens with industrialists. Will congestion tax be imposed on all those cars? 5. Cars like Ola Uber come to drop in South Mumbai, then if they are dropped, the passengers may be affected. Buses like Cityflow also come to South Mumbai and go in the evening, they are parked on Dmello Road, then will they also have to pay congestion tax?Numerous questions arise. This proposal has been made without a complete study and without looking at the ground clarity. In the past, some transport analysts had made such a proposal, which I strongly opposed and when I asked these questions, they did not have the answers.But we all know that this government can take any decision, so I will not be surprised if it decides to impose congestion tax.Read allPost comment
Popular from City
- Earthquake jolts Kolkata, panic among residents
- Watch: Strong earthquake rattles Kolkata, residents flee homes, offices in panic
- 5 months, 17 months, and finally freedom: Arvind Kejriwal, Manish Sisodia cleared in Delhi excise case
- Delhi excise policy case: Ex-Delhi CM Arvind Kejriwal, former dy CM Manish Sisodia acquitted
- Haryana govt official jumps to death from 6th floor of civil secretariat in Chandigarh; workplace stress angle probed
end of article
Trending Stories
- India GDP Q3 Growth Data 2026 Live Updates: First GDP data under new series to be released today
- Earthquake jolts Kolkata, panic among residents
- We drove 2,000 km in an EV across Maharashtra: The highway was effortless, the charging wasn’t
- ‘No words feel enough’: Former cricketers stand in solidarity with Rinku Singh after father’s passing
- Pakistan-Afghanistan tensions live updates: Loud explosions rock Kabul after Pakistan launches major attack on Afghanistan
- Indore-Pune Air India Express flight’s rough landing causes scare for 160 flyers
- Delhi High Court order: Tax Department can’t impose Black Money law on ‘involuntary residents’ to get foreign asset information
Featured in city
08:03 5 months, 17 months, and finally freedom: Arvind Kejriwal, Manish Sisodia cleared in Delhi excise case- Earthquake jolts Kolkata, panic among residents
08:03 Rouse Avenue Court Discharge Order: All 23 accused cleared in excise case; CBI probe criticised04:27 O Panneerselvam Joins DMK: Former CM switches sides before polls; seat likely for him in Theni- Un-fare deal: Namma Metro fare hike sparks backlash as Bengaluru commuters shift back to private vehicles
- Haryana govt official jumps to death from 6th floor of civil secretariat in Chandigarh; workplace stress angle probed
Photostories
- Mumbai’s Bellasis flyover rebuilt in 15 months, opens four months early
- Why is meat traditionally eaten in several parts of India during Holi?
- 10 of the world’s most expensive cities for luxury living right now
- Kitchen Hacks: 6 common pressure cooker mistakes to avoid and dos and don'ts to follow
- Rashmika Mandanna-Vijay Deverakonda to Katrina Kaif-Vicky Kaushal: Star weddings that sent the internet into frenzy
- Somatic practices for each Chakra: Simple movements to balance your mind, body and energy
- The Vanasingaram weave that made Vijay Deverakonda’s wedding look iconic: History, draping style and price breakdown
- ‘Truth wins’: Arvind Kejriwal, Manish Sisodia break down after major court relief in excise case
- Top 8 vegetarian foods that help boost vitamin B12 naturally
- Deadliest female animals you should fear more than the males
Videos
06:01 Ex-Afghan Mp Mariam Solaimankhil Blasts Pakistan Over Civilian Killings, Echoes India’s Stance08:16 'Zero Tolerance And Full Transparency': CEC Gyanesh Kumar Says Tamil Nadu Polls A Matter Of Pride03:51 'Prachand' Moment: President Murmu Flies in Indigenous Combat Helicopter Near India-Pak Border04:19 From First Date To Diplomatic Stage, Netanyahu Links Love Story To India08:03 'I Am Not Corrupt': Arvind Kejriwal Breaks Down As Court Frees Him, Sisodia In Excise Policy Case04:27 Panneerselvam Switches To DMK Camp, CM Stalin Resets Tamil Nadu Political Chessboard Ahead Of Polls06:46 Pakistan Launches Operation Ghazab, Declares Open War Against Afghanistan As India Keeps Close Watch19:13 'AI Only Works With What Has Been Expressed So Far': Prasoon Joshi Gets Candid At DNPA 202605:07 Indian Navy’s New Hunter, INS Anjadip To Targets Submarines Close To Coast
Up Next